QUICKPATENTS VIDEO TRANSCRIPT Polished for readability and removal of filler words, stutters, and false starts Hi, I'm Kevin Prince, owner of QuickPatents. Thank you so much for watching this video. I'm going to cover the basic questions I get asked most often. Hopefully, this will make it clear what patents are all about, what type of patent you should pursue, and answer many of your questions before we talk. That way, we can get the most out of our time together, whether we're speaking on the phone or by Zoom. Let's start with the basics. If you've seen this video before, you still might want to watch it again. There's a lot of information here, and you may pick up a few useful nuggets, especially when we get into foreign patents. WHAT IS A PATENT? I get asked every day, "Do I need a patent to make and sell my product?" The answer is no. People sell products all day long without patents. A patent is not permission to make, use, or sell something. It's a right to stop someone else from making, using, or selling an invention in the jurisdiction covered by the patent. For example, if you have a granted U.S. patent, you can stop competitors from making, using, or selling an infringing product in the United States and its territories. This is very helpful if you're selling on Amazon. Amazon doesn't want to infringe your patent, so it may remove infringing listings if competitors are flagrantly violating your patent rights. That's what a patent is: a barrier to entry for competitors. Hopefully, it's one of several barriers you can use. If you can get a patent, that's great. It becomes an asset and can help you capture more market share for your product. WHAT DOES "PATENT PENDING" MEAN? Whenever you file a patent application, whether it's a design application, a provisional utility application, or a nonprovisional utility application, you can legally say "patent pending." Some people use "patent pending" as though it's another name for a provisional application, but that's not correct. Even a design patent application gives you patent-pending status. I like to think of patent pending as a big "No Trespassing" sign on a piece of property you don't own yet. Hopefully, would-be competitors will see that sign and realize you've already beaten them to the Patent Office. Why should they follow you? Why spend money on the same product if you're already there? Since 2013, the United States has operated under a first-inventor-to-file system. Getting to the Patent Office first is important. The "No Trespassing" sign tells people that if there is a patent to be had on this invention, you may end up holding it, and they'll have to deal with you. Why bother entering that market? You'll never know whom you scare away with your patent-pending status, because those competitors may never enter the marketplace. You'll never hear about them. But what if someone copies you while your application is pending? People often ask whether patent pending gives them protection. The answer is, not in the sense of being able to stop someone immediately. A competitor may copy your product, and you generally can't stop them based solely on a pending application. It's like someone setting up a lemonade stand on that property with your "No Trespassing" sign. You don't own the property yet, so you can't evict them until you have the deed. Likewise, you generally must wait until the patent issues before enforcing the patent. In the United States, a utility patent might take a year and a half to three years after filing to issue. For design patents, it might take a year to a year and a half. That can be an extended wait. There are strategies we can discuss to help get a patent issued more quickly, but it's important to remember that being patent pending doesn't mean you can immediately stop a competitor. I could file a patent application today on an iPhone and legally say "patent pending" for that application. That doesn't mean I'd obtain rights to the iPhone. It's probably a sure way to meet the attorneys at Apple, so don't do that. DESIGN PATENTS AND UTILITY PATENTS There are basically two types of patents we're going to discuss: design patents and utility patents. We won't talk about plant patents because I don't think I've had a single plant patent case in more than 20 years. A design patent protects the ornamental or aesthetic appearance of a product: the way it looks. It doesn't protect the way it works. A utility patent is what most people mean when they talk about patents. Utility patents protect how something works, or its theory of operation, regardless of what it looks like. I like to use sunglasses as an example. If you have a unique style of sunglasses but they work the same way as every other pair of sunglasses, you would be looking at a design patent. You couldn't get a utility patent on the ordinary way those sunglasses work, because that technology has been around for a long time. But suppose you were the first person to invent polarized lenses. In that case, you'd want a utility patent because you're protecting the technology. If a competitor made sunglasses with polarized lenses, you wouldn't care what their glasses looked like. You'd care that they were using the technology covered by your utility patent. Utility and design patents aren't mutually exclusive. I've obtained both types for the same product. They simply protect different aspects of the product. PROVISIONAL AND NONPROVISIONAL UTILITY APPLICATIONS There's a lot of confusion about provisional patents. A provisional patent application is a type of utility patent application. Utility applications come in two forms: provisional and nonprovisional, sometimes called a regular application. A provisional application is temporary. It allows you to say "patent pending," but it only lasts for one year. Within that year, you generally need to file a nonprovisional application to maintain the benefit of the provisional filing. The nonprovisional application is the one that gets in line at the Patent Office to be examined. I call the provisional a placeholder in line. It saves your filing date, what we call your priority date, so that when you later file the nonprovisional application, it can receive the benefit of that earlier filing date for subject matter properly supported by the provisional. The provisional itself won't be examined. It waits for you to file the nonprovisional, and then the examination process can begin. I see two advantages to filing a provisional application and one drawback. The first advantage is that it's less expensive up front. We don't have to do as much work. We still need to explain how to make and use the invention, but we don't have to prepare a full set of claims or all the other sections that typically go into a nonprovisional application. I work a little differently from many patent practitioners. When I write your provisional application, I put substantial work into material that will also go into the nonprovisional application. So when it's time to file the nonprovisional a year later, I don't charge the full price again. I charge the difference. At QuickPatents, we use flat fees. I'm not going to give the amounts in this video because I'd like the video to remain useful for a few years, and Patent Office filing and issue fees change too. Our current prices are on our order forms and pricing page at QuickPatents.com. You can look up a service, open its order form, and see the pricing there. So the first advantage of a provisional application is the lower up-front cost, spreading some of the expense over the year. If you go directly to a nonprovisional application, you'll pay the full nonprovisional price up front. The second advantage is the opportunity to develop and improve the product during that year. We can include those improvements in the later nonprovisional application, instead of necessarily filing multiple nonprovisional applications as the product evolves. Filing several applications can get expensive. If you're still tinkering with your invention and making improvements, filing a provisional first may be worth considering. Then, when you're ready with the more complete design, you can file the nonprovisional. You don't have to wait the whole year. You can file it after six months if you want, but you generally need to file within 12 months to claim the benefit of the provisional application. If you let that year pass without filing the appropriate follow-on application, the provisional expires and won't provide the priority benefit you were planning on. Now for the drawback: nothing happens in the examination process while your provisional is pending. It simply sits there waiting for your nonprovisional application. If you wait 10 months to file the nonprovisional, that will likely delay issuance by roughly 10 months, because you're not yet in line for examination. That's important if you're worried competitors will copy you quickly. Waiting longer to get the issued patent gives them more time to compete while you don't yet have an enforceable patent. If you want the patent in your hands as quickly as possible, going directly to the nonprovisional application may be the better option. PUBLIC DISCLOSURE AND THE ONE-YEAR GRACE PERIOD Let's talk about whether you can still file a patent application. Sometimes I speak with clients who started selling a product three years ago and now want a patent. That can be too late. In the United States, there is generally a one-year grace period for certain disclosures originating from the inventor. If your own public disclosure or sale triggers the grace period, you generally need to file within that year. Otherwise, your own disclosure can be used against you. That grace period gives you an opportunity to test the market. You can see whether the product will sell and pay for itself before spending money on patent protection. If it turns out to be a dog and doesn't sell, you may decide not to pursue the patent. If it does well, you can file within the applicable grace period. But that's a risky approach if you're interested in foreign patents. Many countries don't have the same grace period the United States has. Suppose you launch your product on Amazon today and file a patent application a month from now. In many countries, that earlier public disclosure could prevent you from obtaining patent protection. For example, China has strict novelty requirements. If you disclose your invention publicly before filing, you may lose patent rights there. It's something you should think about before you launch. Most of my clients don't pursue foreign patents. The U.S. market is large, and foreign patent protection can be expensive. But if you're considering foreign protection, the best way to keep your options open is generally to file before publicly disclosing the invention. This is especially important if you're thinking about licensing your invention to another company. A potential licensee might want the ability to protect and sell the product internationally. If you've already lost foreign filing rights, that could make the opportunity less attractive. So if licensing is part of your plan, consider filing before public disclosure. Foreign patents are expensive. Only about 10% of my clients pursue them, and one of the most common reactions I hear is how expensive they are. Keep that in mind as you plan. LICENSING VERSUS MANUFACTURING There are basically two ways to make money from a product: build a business around it yourself or license it to someone else. Think about owning a restaurant building. Suppose you have the property, the building is ready, the inspections are complete, and you can open for business. You have two choices. You could operate the restaurant yourself. That means developing the menu, hiring cooks, ordering food, doing the marketing, and dealing with inspectors. It's probably a full-time job. If it's successful, you get the lion's share of the profit. Or you could rent the building to a restaurant company like Denny's. They already know how to run a restaurant. You let them do the work and collect a steady rent check. That's passive income. You do less work, but you also get a smaller share of the profits. That's how I think about the difference between manufacturing and licensing an invention. Inventors often ask me, "Can I just patent my product and sell the patent for a million dollars?" That would be like trying to sell the restaurant building before anyone knows whether a restaurant will succeed at that location. The business hasn't been tested, so it's unlikely someone will simply pay a million dollars for the patent. You generally need to test the product in the marketplace. If it succeeds, someone might want to buy it. Or you may want to keep the rights and license the product, collecting a royalty check over time. Royalties are often around 3% to 5%, depending on the arrangement. For example, if your licensee sells $1,000 worth of products to Walmart at wholesale prices, a 3% to 5% royalty would be $30 to $50. If those sales happen across many Walmart stores, the royalties can add up. I know inventors, including some clients, who make their living from four or five licensing agreements. That income supports their lifestyle of tinkering in the garage. What a life! If you're qualified to run a startup, that might be the better path for you. But think about all the responsibilities: marketing, manufacturing, logistics, shipping, warehousing, picking and packing orders, and setting up an Amazon store. If you already run a company that makes similar products, adding another product line may make perfect sense. If you're new to inventing, have a full-time job, and don't want to handle all those operations, licensing may be worth considering. If you want to license your invention, I recommend the book One Simple Idea by Stephen Key, K-E-Y. It has a yellow cover. Stephen is a guru of licensing. He's made millions of dollars through licensing deals and has practical advice on how to get started. PATENT SEARCHES AND APPLICATIONS As I mentioned, we have order forms for all our services. If you're considering a utility patent application, provisional or nonprovisional, I'd usually recommend starting with a patent search. Let's search first and see whether someone has already patented the invention. There's no point spending a lot of money on an application if someone patented the same thing five years ago. That's actually how I got started in this business. I had an idea and hired a local patent agent to search it. We found the exact same invention patented 10 years earlier. It was discouraging, of course, but at least I could move on to my next project. I also found it fascinating to read that patent. It was like reading a patent on my own idea. It showed that the idea was patentable; I just wasn't the first person to think of it. Someone else's name was on it, but the information was the same. That experience taught me how much detail goes into a patent application, what the drawings should look like, and how the process works. That's how I got my start as an inventor. Thankfully, I've had five patents since then that have been successful. DESIGN PATENT ADVANTAGES For design patents, you probably don't need a search in many cases. About 95% of the time, in my experience, design patents are approved. Utility applications are different. They frequently receive an initial rejection, after which we work with the examiner to reach claim language that both the examiner and the inventor can accept. Design applications tend to be more straightforward. About 95% of the time, in my experience, the first substantive response is a notice of allowance. You pay the issue fee, and the patent typically issues afterward. Design patents have several advantages. They're less expensive. They tend to move through the Patent Office more reliably, with fewer prior-art problems. Prior art can still be an issue, of course, but in my experience it's less frequent. Design patents may also issue more quickly: perhaps a year to a year and a half, compared with a year and a half to three years for utility patents. A U.S. design patent generally lasts 15 years from its issue date, and there are no maintenance fees. I like design patents. Even if you're pursuing a utility patent, consider whether a design patent could also make sense for your product. It can be a hedge against something going wrong with your utility application. It doesn't work for every invention, but if it fits, it may be worth filing both. Then you can accurately say you have multiple patents pending. It's a bigger "No Trespassing" sign. Of course, for something like a chemical formulation, you may have no ornamental product design to protect, so you'd be looking at utility patent protection. For utility inventions, I generally recommend a search. For design patents, unless the design is especially simple or there is a particular reason to investigate prior designs, I often recommend going straight to the application. A search might cost a substantial fraction of the application itself, so it may not make economic sense. CONFIDENTIALITY AND DISCLOSING YOUR INVENTION Let's talk about our order forms. I'm asking you to share your secrets because I need to write the patent application. A patent application explains how to make and use the invention, so I need to understand how your product works. You shouldn't hold back important technical details. Naturally, people ask about confidentiality. Will I keep the information secret? Yes. I've been doing this for over 20 years. You can also check on the disciplinary history of a patent practitioner you're thinking of hiring. The Patent Office has an Office of Enrollment and Discipline, or OED, that handles practitioner discipline and related questions. Patent practitioners have confidentiality obligations toward clients and prospective clients. That's why many patent attorneys won't sign a separate nondisclosure agreement; they consider it redundant. I'm happy to sign nondisclosure agreements, though. I think it's a good habit for inventors to get into. If you're uncomfortable sharing information without one, we can sign an NDA so you have it in writing. You can also look at my online reviews and judge for yourself. Once you're comfortable showing me what you have, I can help direct you more effectively. That's one reason I made this video: rather than spend our entire conversation covering the basics, we can use our time to focus on your specific product. I may be able to tell you whether a utility patent makes the most sense, whether you should pursue a design patent, or whether both might be appropriate. You can fill out the order forms before we talk. Then, if you have questions about the forms, we can go over them during our call. If you'd like a nondisclosure agreement, it's the first form on the Forms menu at QuickPatents.com. Fill it out and I'll sign it electronically and send it back to you. PATENT AGENT VERSUS PATENT ATTORNEY Another question I get is, "You're a patent agent and an engineer, not a patent attorney. What's the difference?" Basically, I can represent you before the Patent Office on patent matters, just as a registered patent attorney can. What I can't do is represent you in court. If I obtain your patent and someone later infringes it, I can't represent you in a patent infringement lawsuit. I'm not an attorney, and litigation is a court matter. I also can't act as your attorney for general legal matters, such as drafting or advising on licensing agreements or negotiating nondisclosure agreements with a factory. Those involve legal work outside my authorized patent practice. But when it comes to patent matters before the Patent Office, such as patent applications and prosecution, I can help you just as a patent attorney can. Communications concerning patent prosecution can also be privileged, subject to the applicable rules. Congress established a system in which registered patent agents can practice in this specific area of patent law, what we call patent prosecution: obtaining patents through the Patent Office. Patent agents may be less expensive because they often don't have the overhead of patent attorneys. Look at the services and pricing and decide what's best for you. That's my niche. That's my lane. We've been doing this for almost 20 years and have obtained something like 2,800 patents for our clients over that time. Not too bad! I'm looking forward to speaking with you. Hopefully, this video has been helpful. Feel free to watch it again, and if you still have questions, jot them down. We'll get them answered when we speak. Thanks so much for watching.